What every Property Pro must Understand About Kickback Rules

Navigate the marketplace shifts with Inman Select in your corner.

The biggest New york city genuine estate event

Blueprint Las Vegas
Inman On Tour Texas
Luxury Connect
All approaching events

Inman Intel
Intel Index
Discover more

Data and research study into what's taking place today - and tomorrow - in domestic property and proptech.

Inman Access Video
Tips, How-Tos, & Guides
Realtor.com PRO Resources
Tech Reviews
Insider Webinars
Handbooks
Essential Guides
Find out more

An immersive video experience bringing you realty's finest specialists.

See all

The most coveted awards in property, recognizing greatness throughout the industry.

Power Players
New York City Power Brokers
MLS Reinvented
Marketing All-Stars
Future Leaders in Real Estate
Golden I Club
Best of Finance
Inman Innovators
AI Awards
Best of Proptech

About Inman
Email Newsletters
Press Center
Advertising & Sponsorship
Customer Support

- Log in Subscribe
- - Account Settings
- Contact Us
- Log Out

Inman On Tour Texas is around the corner!
Track your market with 2 new tools
2025 property events calendar
TikTok (not HGTV) improved this biz
Must-know kickback guidelines
5 texts to send today

What every realty pro should learn about kickback rules

Canva

RESPA is the greatest celebration foul in property. Compliance professional Summer Goralik discusses the guidelines and stresses that anything less than full compliance can be a career-ending bad move.

Quick Read

- The Realty Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), enforced by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), prohibits kickbacks and referral costs in property property transactions involving federally related mortgage loans. It's designed to protect consumers and promote settlement openness.
- Exemptions to RESPA include authentic payments for actual services, cooperative brokerage recommendations within licensed capability and revealed associated company arrangements, which permit ownership returns but no referral charges.
- RESPA offenses consist of concealed referrals with gifts, payments tied to referrals, and steering customers to favored companies, risking fines, license loss, and reputational damage.
- Compliance requires clear disclosures, adherence to state and federal laws, avoiding compensated recommendations and comprehensive paperwork.

In the high-pressure world of property sales, every agent quickly finds out the classic saying: "Always be closing." It's the lifeblood of the service, right? The offer, the commission, the win.

If you have actually ever seen Glengarry Glen Ross, a timeless dark funny drama, you understand how completely honest and unforgiving the sales video game can be. The motion picture's legendary line, "Coffee's for closers," is less about caffeine, obviously, and more about success: Who earns it and who doesn't.

But there's another mantra every real estate specialist ought to live by, one that's far less catchy or popular however much more important in the long run: Always be complying. (Did I simply coin that?)

And when it pertains to the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), compliance may be the most essential closing technique a professional can embrace. Without it, it's not simply dangerous organization; it's what I call a career-ending party foul in this market.

Just as mastering the art of closing separates leading producers from the rest, understanding and respecting RESPA is a prerequisite in property. It separates thriving careers from regulative nightmares.

So, where do we begin? At the top, naturally. Let's dig into the essentials, check out essential guardrails, and paint a photo of what RESPA compliance and diligence look like in the field.

What Is RESPA?

RESPA, enacted in 1974 and enforced by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), is a federal law designed to safeguard customers by promoting transparency in real estate settlements. Among other things, it prohibits kickbacks and referral charges between settlement provider that synthetically inflate costs.

The law uses to a large range of service providers included in the settlement procedure, including property brokers, mortgage brokers and lending institutions, to name simply a few. However, RESPA is only activated when the deal involves domestic genuine residential or commercial property and a federally related mortgage loan.

Though complex and often complicated, RESPA's objective is simple: Keep the settlement process truthful and fair. The customer is the focus, and security is the objective. Among its key arrangements, RESPA needs clear disclosure of all estimated or real transaction expenses and empowers customers to look around for settlement company.

Perhaps RESPA is most famous for what it strictly prohibits: giving or getting any "thing of worth" in exchange for referrals associated with settlement services such as title insurance coverage, escrow or inspections. That indicates clear commissions, no disguised referral charges and no presents.

So, exactly what counts as a "thing of value"? Think broadly. It goes far beyond charges or commissions and can consist of stock dividends, discount rates, presents, journeys - the list goes on. In fact, a CFPB attorney as soon as informed me that not even a stick of chewing gum is legal if it's connected to or conditioned upon a recommendation.

Important exemptions to RESPA

No RESPA overview is complete without a quick evaluation of its exemptions. That is, while RESPA prohibits many recommendation charge arrangements, it also consists of important exemptions under Section 8 that permit certain charges, salaries, settlement or other payments without restriction. Notable exemptions include:

Authentic payments for services or products: Payments made to anybody as an authentic income, compensation or other payment for products actually provided or services in fact carried out are allowed [12 CFR § 1024.14(g)( 1 )(iv)]
Cooperative brokerage and referral arrangements: Cooperative brokerage and recommendation arrangements between property representatives and brokers are permitted, but just when all parties are acting within their licensed brokerage capability. This exemption does not use to cost plans between genuine estate brokers and mortgage brokers, or in between mortgage brokers themselves [12 CFR § 1024.14(g)( 1 )(v)]
Affiliated company arrangements (ABAs): ABAs are allowed if particular conditions are met, including full disclosure to the consumer - normally through the ABA disclosure form in Appendix D of RESPA (which I frequently show clients). Under these arrangements, the only thing of worth got can be a return on ownership interest or a franchise relationship, which suggests referral fees from associated entities are forbidden. Crucially, customers must keep the freedom to choose any settlement provider; they can not be needed to use a particular provider [12 CFR § 1024.15 et seq.] Although these exemptions exist, and they are not extensive, some critics argue that the realty market limits true customer choice by guiding clients toward preferred suppliers, raising issues about the spirit of customer liberty that RESPA was meant to secure. But let's put a pin because notion for a minute and keep moving through our RESPA crash course.

Additional factors to consider on charges and market price

To showcase how complex and not simple RESPA can be, it is very important to likewise understand the following regulative guidance regarding payments and costs (which I am pulling straight from the law itself):

"The Bureau might investigate high costs to see if they are the result of a recommendation fee or a split of a cost. If the payment of a thing of worth bears no affordable relationship to the marketplace worth of the items or services provided, then the excess is not for services or goods actually carried out or provided. These realities might be utilized as proof of an offense of section 8 and may act as a basis for a RESPA investigation. High rates standing alone are not proof of a RESPA violation.

The value of a referral (i.e., the worth of any extra company acquired therefore) is not to be taken into consideration in identifying whether the payment surpasses the sensible value of such goods, facilities or services. The reality that the transfer of the important things of value does not result in a boost in any charge made by the person providing the thing of worth is unimportant in figuring out whether the act is prohibited" [12 CFR § 1024.14(g)( 2) line breaks included for clarity]

The dos and do n'ts: Playing within RESPA's guardrails

Let's break down this complex body of law into a couple of workable (and hopefully unforgettable) pieces. RESPA has clear guardrails:

Don't offer or accept gifts, discount rates or payments tied to referrals.
Do spend for legitimate services rendered, not for the recommendation itself.
Do reveal ABAs completely and transparently, and make sure the disclosure adheres to RESPA requirements.
Don't participate in marketing service contracts without legal counsel, as these can be RESPA landmines.

For those who work better with genuine examples, here are a few activities that are prohibited under RESPA:

A title company pays a broker $500 for every customer referred.
An agent refers borrowers to lending institutions and gets a $100 present card per referral.
A brokerage owns a home warranty business however stops working to reveal the relationship when referring customers.
An escrow holder pays monthly marketing costs to representatives in exchange for referrals.

Honestly, there is no scarcity of circumstances. In truth, this short article is virtually written on the heels of yet another case including supposed RESPA violations: a marketing service agreement between a realty brokerage and a lender, in which homebuyers claim in six separate claims that a North Carolina brokerage guided them to utilize its partner loan provider. As a result, they state they paid greater interest rates and discount rate points on their loans than they would have if they had shopped around.

Similar kickback issues are explored in a current article about an escrow company presumably compensating agents for company recommendations.

Listen, there will always be an example or headline - simply don't be one of them. A smart rule of thumb for RESPA compliance: assume a recommendation cost is illegal till you've safely confirmed otherwise.

When kickbacks cross legal lines

Having spent years examining realty licensees for non-compliant activities during my time at the Department of Real Estate, I am no stranger to illegal kickback plans. In California realty, this isn't simply theoretical. A typical plan I've witnessed, both while working for the state and later as an expert, involves brokers financially incentivizing their representatives to use the company's in-house escrow divisions. This is an illegal practice under both California law and RESPA.

I co-wrote a thorough piece on the parallels and disconnects in between federal RESPA and California's recommendation cost laws, which still survives on the DRE's website. One method to consider the legal characteristics surrounding recommendation costs is this: RESPA sets the federal standard, whereas states typically layer additional enforcement rules, developing a complex compliance landscape.

Consider California's B&P Code § 10177.4 - a family referral in my compliance world - which prohibits recommendation costs for services consisting of escrow, title and pest control. Although it covers a smaller sized set of service companies, its scope is broader than RESPA's, using to transactions without guaranteed loans and to residential or commercial property types such as commercial and industrial.

In essence, depending on the state, realty licensees may undergo several laws that don't always line up. That's why it's vital for licensees to carefully vet referral fee activities for both state and federal compliance.

Avoid the 'f' word in genuine estate: Tips for professionals

If I'm being completely honest, sometimes I think of RESPA as the "f word" in real estate. I say this half-jokingly, however the truth is, nobody ever says "RESPA" when things are going smoothly. It normally comes up when something has actually gone incorrect, often as the headline of a story alleging misconduct.

The truth is, customers get harmed when settlement provider engage in illegal recommendation cost activities. And it's no better on the other side. Agents tempted to avoid RESPA, whether by using or getting recommendation kickbacks, concealing costs or skirting disclosure, risk more than fines. They endanger their licenses, reputations and incomes.

Ignorance is no reason either. And though this post offers just a teaspoon of knowledge in the huge ocean of RESPA education, here are a couple of principles to remember if you want to endure RESPA compliance.

If you're making or receiving recommendations, make certain:

They're non-compensable or abide by both federal and state laws.
You've disclosed whatever clearly and in composing to customers.
You avoid any type of compensation connected to referrals.

Did I point out that a referral fee plan does not need to be documented in writing to be unlawful? Under RESPA, an arrangement or understanding can be established just through a pattern of activities or a course of conduct.

For example, if a "thing of worth" is received consistently in connection with the volume or value of referred business, that alone can be sufficient to activate enforcement. Put differently, even without a signed contract or specific conversation, the arrangement can still violate the law.

To wrap up these pointers, keep in mind that compliance surpasses feeling in one's bones the rules. Always speak out and ask concerns when something isn't clear or does not feel right. If you are an agent, your responsible broker is an excellent place to start that questions. Document your activities thoroughly - as if you might one day be called to safeguard them in court (though hopefully you won't). This implies keeping emails, texts and any other pertinent interactions.

Diligence not only secures your clients but also safeguards your license and expert track record.

Closing with compliance

If you ask a compliance expert what real success appears like, be prepared to hear the words "regulatory compliance" in my reaction. Boring, right? But believe me, I've seen a lot in the game of genuine estate. The true winners aren't just the best closers; they're the ones who appreciate the rules, safeguard customers and keep their services out of legal hot water.

You can close the most deals and make the highest commissions, however if you lose your license over a single illegal referral, it's meaningless. That's my point: Real success depends on compliance.

Remember: "Always be closing" only works if you're also always complying.